Independent Contractor vs Employee: Know Your Legal Rights
Misclassified as an independent contractor? You may be owed overtime, benefits, and tax refunds. Here is how to tell the difference and what to do about it.
Why Classification Matters
The difference between being classified as an employee (W-2) versus an independent contractor (1099) affects virtually every aspect of your working life. Employees receive minimum wage protection, overtime pay for hours over 40 per week, employer-paid Social Security and Medicare taxes (half of the 15.3 percent), unemployment insurance, workers compensation if injured on the job, protection under anti-discrimination laws, and often health insurance and retirement benefits. Independent contractors receive none of these protections. They pay both halves of Social Security and Medicare (the full 15.3 percent), have no overtime protection, receive no unemployment benefits if work ends, and have no workers compensation coverage. The IRS estimates that millions of workers are misclassified as independent contractors, costing them thousands of dollars per year in lost wages and benefits.
How to Tell If You Are Misclassified
The label your employer uses does not determine your actual classification. What matters is the nature of the working relationship based on several legal tests. The IRS uses a three-factor test examining behavioral control (does the company control how, when, and where you work?), financial control (do you have the opportunity for profit or loss, provide your own tools, and work for multiple clients?), and the type of relationship (is there a written contract, are benefits provided, is the relationship ongoing?). If the company controls your schedule, requires you to work at their location, provides your tools and equipment, prohibits you from working for others, and the relationship looks and feels like employment, you are likely an employee regardless of what your contract says.
Common Signs of Misclassification
You are likely misclassified as an independent contractor if the company sets your work hours and schedule, tells you how to perform the work (not just what result to achieve), requires you to work at their location, provides all tools, equipment, and materials, prohibits you from working for competitors or other clients, pays you hourly or salary rather than by project completion, the relationship is ongoing without a defined project end date, you perform the same work as W-2 employees at the same company, or the company provides training on how to do the job. The more of these factors that apply, the stronger the argument that you should be classified as an employee.
What to Do If You Are Misclassified
If you believe you are misclassified, you have several options. File IRS Form SS-8 requesting the IRS to determine your worker status. This is free and the IRS will investigate and make an official determination. File a complaint with your state labor department, which can investigate and order the employer to reclassify workers and pay back wages, overtime, and benefits. File a wage claim for unpaid overtime with the federal Department of Labor or your state labor board. Consult with an employment attorney, many of whom handle misclassification cases on contingency, meaning you pay nothing upfront and the attorney takes a percentage of any recovery. You can also file an amended tax return to recover the overpaid self-employment taxes from previous years if the IRS determines you were an employee.
Legitimate Independent Contractors
Not all 1099 relationships are misclassification. You are legitimately an independent contractor if you set your own hours and schedule, work for multiple clients, provide your own tools and equipment, have the ability to hire helpers or subcontractors, determine how the work is performed (the client only specifies the result), bear the risk of profit or loss, and market your services to the general public. Many freelancers, consultants, tradespeople, and gig workers are legitimately self-employed. The key question is whether you operate an independent business or whether you are essentially an employee who has been labeled a contractor for the company benefit of avoiding payroll taxes, benefits, and labor law compliance.
Pro Tips
Frequently Asked Questions
Can my employer fire me for filing a misclassification complaint?
Retaliation against workers who file classification complaints is illegal under both federal and state law. If you are terminated after filing a complaint, you have a separate retaliation claim which can result in additional damages. Document any adverse actions taken after you raise classification concerns.
How much money could I be owed if I am misclassified?
The amount depends on your situation. Commonly recovered amounts include unpaid overtime (time and a half for hours over 40 per week), the employer half of Social Security and Medicare taxes (7.65 percent of your pay), unemployment insurance benefits, and in some cases, health insurance and retirement benefits that employees received. For a worker earning $50,000 per year, misclassification can cost $5,000 to $15,000 or more annually.
Does signing a contract saying I am an independent contractor make it true?
No. A contract label does not override the actual working relationship. If the working conditions meet the legal test for employment, you are an employee regardless of what the contract says. Courts and the IRS look at the reality of the relationship, not the paperwork. Many misclassification cases involve workers who signed contractor agreements.
Still stuck? Chat with Daniel now.
Get personalized legal advice help for your specific situation — just $3.
Chat with Daniel Harris — $3 →
